On Being a Giant

Greg Oden is 22 (allegedly), and thus might be the youngest player in league history to be, by general consensus, a draft bust. His numbers tell you he’s an impact player, maybe even an All-Star. His career PER (19.5) is matched by only 23 active players, his Win Share rate (.180/48) by only 11. But you can only help when you’re on the court. He’ll have missed 328 out of a possible 410 regular season games by year’s end, meaning he’s still 13000 minutes away from qualifying for either statistic. I don’t want to ruminate on whether or not he deserves the bust tag–as Snoop Pearson would have you know, deserve got nothin’ to do with it. Instead, I’d like to ask: what were we really expecting? Has Oden been a disappointment? Or are we just tearing down what we never should have built up in the first place?

There are 3 players currently in the NBA who match Oden’s listed height (7’0″) and weight (285 lbs.): Shaquille O’Neal, Andrew Bynum, and Yao Ming. Illustrious company, but a list that also reads like the attendance sheet for a Plastar Fasictis Anonymous meeting. In total, that group (excluding Oden) have appeared in 1929 out of a possible 2510 regular season games. That’s about 77%–on average, a 63-game season. That figure, however, is slightly inflated by the Man of Steel’s durability–he’s stayed the healthiest, in a career twice as long as Yao’s or Bynum’s. And if you include Oden in the analysis, active NBA players of his dimensions have appeared in 73% of possible games – a shade under 60 games a year. All of them have had at least one season where they sat out most of the year; 2 of the 4 have missed at least one entire season.

In the pursuit of athletic excellence, we convince ourselves that athletes’ bodies are fit to do things that fly in the face of medical science. Dozens of MLB pitchers are now using elbows reconstructed through Tommy John surgery (inserting a tendon from elsewhere in the body into the elbow) after the repeated, unnatural act of throwing a baseball the way they’ve been properly instructed since Little League shredded their ulnar collateral ligament. And the NFL is finally starting to pay attention to the mounting evidence about the extreme likelihood and long-term effect of concussions from playing football at all levels, with drastic rule changes perhaps its only recourse to address the problem. We’re disappointed to hear about a hard-throwing pitcher blowing out his arm, or an ex-linebacker showing early signs of neurological deterioration. But the only people still surprised by these stories are the ones who haven’t been paying attention. Shouldn’t the sidelining of a 7-ft, 300-lb center be added to that category of things we probably should’ve known better about?

A lot of people are now asking whether Oden is injury prone or if he’s merely been the victim of isolated, freak accidents. Really? Of course he’s injury prone. He’s 7 feet tall. He’d be prone to injury if he never picked up a basketball. Think of the biggest person you know (who, in all likelihood, is not a 7-footer). How many assorted leg issues have they had?

We remember when this works out well–Shaq, Olajuwon, Abdul-Jabbar. They stayed pretty healthy, and each won multiple titles in the process. But drafting size early, you’re just as likely to end up with a Sam Bowie or Brad Daugherty–a talented guy who simply can’t stay on the court. It could be worse. Looking for a franchise center, teams will sometimes see the right frame and think the basketball part can be filled in later–Aleksandar Radojevic, DeSagana Diop, and Robert Swift all went early in recent drafts. The point is, hitting on an O’Neal or Olajuwon is like winning the lottery.

The Blazers aren’t dumb. They knew the risk they were taking, but a dominant big man is a quicker ticket to a championship than a dominant small forward. So it didn’t work out for them. They aimed high, flew too close to the sun, and got burned. Oden’s only sin was flashing the type of talent that puts visions of Larry O’Brien trophies in executives’ heads. He’s got a lot more Brad Daugherty in him than Michael Olowokandi. Daugherty played 548 games, and played them well. Let’s hope Oden can get to that number. That would be a great success, and there is some precedent–Zydrunas Ilgauskas missed 185 games in his first 4 seasons. Oden has 466 games to match Daugherty. That’s a far more reasonable goal for him now than to be the next Olajuwon. What’s lost when we wonder about what could have been is that it was the most reasonable goal to begin with.

Thoughts? Qualms? Feeling lonely? Comment on the article or e-mail us at AGRbasketball (at) gmail (dot) com. Don’t forget to follow @AGRbasketball on Twitter and to like us on Facebook.

This entry was posted in NBA analysis. Bookmark the permalink.

14 Responses to On Being a Giant

  1. Charlatan says:

    Nice article. I would also observe the Olajuwon was quite a bit smaller than the other folks you listed, at 6’10” and playing at 250-255lbs. Shaq is amazingly durable for his size.

  2. Shiv says:

    I agree with Charlatan. Olajuwan should be replaced in this article with Wilt Chamberlain who was the proptotypical 7-foot 300-lb giant.

  3. ac says:

    Shaq is probably the most physically gifted player ever. His rookie draft combine numbers are just ridiculous…legit 7’1″, 300 lbs, 35″ vertical, 7’7″ wingspan; I don’t know that anyone’s ever gonna hit the basketball physical size jackpot like that ever again.

  4. well i think olajuwan should be replaced…..he is a bit smaller..then the others

  5. Phreesh says:

    What about David Robinson? He looked like a cut, muscular guard in a seven foot body.

    Of course, he also had his share of health issues.

  6. thecornerthree says:

    I think ultiamtely this comes down the the lack of parody in the NBA and the necessary risks to win championships. There was only a slight chance that Oden would turn out healthy and dominant like O’Neal or Abdul-Jabar. But that chance was worth taking when there are 30 other teams looking to win a title, and titles bring in fans, and fans bring in money.

  7. Dave says:

    Oden is listed at 250 lbs at Basketball Reference, which brings in a whole bunch of other durable big men … I make it over 20. Bogut and Ilgauskas seem like reasonable comparisons …

    Diop, Fesenko, and Hibbert all should be on your list of active 7 footers over 275 lbs. Paints a slightly different picture of what might be likely with that size body assuming of course that Oden is 275 not 250 …

    It’s pretty obvious that Oden has knee problems. Something Shaq and Yao don’t (yes knees are different to feet – just ask B Roy).
    It’s also pretty obvious that Portland have a poor medical team their history of injured players far exceeds what you might expects – Phoenix, on the other hand managed to coax a 75 game season out of Shaq – something the Celtics are very thankful for.

    Managing injuries is a big part of the Modern NBA, just ask Rondo about his back, broken pinkie anyone?

  8. slickmilicic says:

    Good finds Dave…I looked at NBA site numbers, and looked at guys who are regular contributors (20+ mpg) of 3+ years tenure b/c otherwise it’s just too hard to tease games missed due to injury from DNP-CD’s. I should have clarified that. Olajuwon is indeed smaller (well, lighter)–not trying to group him with Yao + Shaq + Bynum, just saying how far a dominant big man will take you (hence Portland’s gamble).

  9. Justin says:

    It should be noted that Roy Hibbert at 7′ 2″ and 280 played 70 games in his rookie year, 81 last year, and has played every game thus far in a break-out . Also, Brook Lopez is in his third year and hasn’t yet missed a game at 7′ 0″ and 270.

  10. Pingback: AGR Player of the Week(end): Bryant Reeves on the Vancouver Grizzlies | Alone in the Green Room

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s